Many people who start piano stop. Children stop, teenagers stop, and adults who came back after years stop again. This article looks at what research actually says about why, what it does not say, and one reason that gets little attention: how much work it takes to read the page.

How many people stop

The clearest numbers come from a 2021 study by Ruth and Müllensiefen, published in PLOS ONE. They followed 3,303 students aged 10 to 17 in the UK and Germany. About half had stopped music lessons and other musical activities by age 17, most of them between 15 and 17. Homes with less music in them and age predicted who stopped. The study covers all instruments, and piano players were less likely than guitar players to stop at 16 and 17.

For piano specifically, a 2017 Canadian study by Gerelus, Comeau and Swirp compared 55 former piano students with 153 who were still learning. The authors call dropout before a moderate level a frequent problem, and they also say research on it is modest. Their sample was fairly uniform, mostly upper middle class families in western Canada.

One thing the data does not show is that more people are quitting than before. The UK Making Music survey from 2014, run for the exam board ABRSM, found seven in ten children playing an instrument, more than in its earlier surveys. Anyone who tells you piano dropout is rising is saying more than the evidence does.

Why people say they stop

  • Loss of interest, and other things taking the time: school, work, other activities. These were the main reasons in the 2014 Making Music survey, for children and adults.
  • Feeling less able. In a 2013 Australian follow-up by Evans, McPherson and Davidson, people who stopped felt less competent, less connected to others and less in control around the time they stopped.
  • Life changes, for adults. Pitts and Robinson (2016) found that adult amateurs lapse mostly at transitions such as university, a new job or a baby, and when the music no longer fits their goals or ability.
  • Teachers see it too. In the same UK survey almost half of teachers named poor student motivation and lack of support among the hard parts of the job.

What nobody knows yet

No study we found asked people whether reading music was the reason they stopped. None of these papers singles out notation. Nobody has measured how often students arrive at lessons unprepared, or why. And there is no survey of why adults who return to the piano struggle with reading in particular. So everything in the next two sections is reasoning, and we label it that way.

The reading load

Picture a slow piece in E major. Four sharps in the key signature, so every F, C, G and D is raised for the whole piece. In bar 12 a natural sign cancels one of them, but only until the bar line. The right hand has a chord whose top note sits on a ledger line, and the left hand is in the bass clef doing something else. All of this has to be sorted out at the moment the note is due.

Sight-reading studies agree that this has a cost. In Meinz and Hambrick (2010), practice accounted for about half of the differences between pianists, and working memory capacity added more. Herrero and Carriedo (2019) saw a similar pattern in 131 music students. Aiba and Sakaguchi (2018) found that even skilled pianists made mistakes on notes far above or below the staff, and Perra and colleagues (2025) found that accidentals slowed less experienced readers more than experts. These studies don't say reading makes people quit. They say it takes a big share of attention while you play.

Joy or homework

Ophir Atar, who created iCanPiano, sees it like this. Piano is supposed to be the fun part of the week. A child will put up with some suffering for homework, because homework is not optional. Piano is optional, so when every practice session means decoding the page note by note, the music never quite arrives and the joy goes first. The dream of playing slips away, comes back, and slips away again.

His test is simple. Few adults would spend their free evenings decoding symbols for fun, with the music only showing up weeks later. If adults would not do it, it is fair to ask why children and beginners are expected to. The research above fits with this: people stop when they feel less able and when interest fades. Whether reading load is a big part of that has not been measured.

Ophir has ADHD, and he says that once the sharp and flat signs were off the page, he started playing classical and other pieces he never thought he would have the patience to read. That is his own experience.

What could change

  • Get to real music sooner. A piece you love, even one line of it, gives you a reason to sit down tomorrow.
  • Take away decoding where you can. Fewer symbols to hold in memory leaves more attention for the hands and the sound.
  • Keep several pieces going. When one gets stuck, another still sounds good.
  • Plan for life changes. If you stop for a new job or a baby, coming back is normal. Pitts and Robinson found that people with good earlier experiences returned more easily.

Reading is only one reason people stop, and we have no data that it is the main one. iCanPiano Style takes one step of decoding off the page: the sharp and flat signs. Rhythm, two hands and practice stay. If your trouble is keeping motivation in the first weeks, our article on why adults quit piano and how to keep going has habits for that.

iCanPianoWhat you see is what you play

iCanPiano is a sheet music player for adults returning to the piano, with real pieces from Bach and Mozart to Beethoven and Chopin. It uses iCanPiano Style: a note that falls on a black key has no sharp or flat sign. The note head itself is half black and half white:

Standard notationiCanPiano Style
  • F sharp: the right half is black, so you play the black key just right of F.
  • B flat: the left half is black, so you play the black key just left of B.
  • A note that is fully black or fully white goes on a white key.

You learn the idea in about half a minute. It can feel a little odd for the first few minutes if you come from standard notation, and then most people find it easier. Standard notation is always shown next to it, so you can switch back at any time. We don't promise faster reading. We say it is easier, and chords especially are easier to see.

You can play along with the player: mute the left hand or the right, slow it down, and set the volume to what suits you. If you prefer paper, the pages can be printed in iCanPiano Style.

iCanPiano works in your browser at icanpiano.net. An app for iPhone and iPad is on its way. It listens as you play, through the microphone or a MIDI keyboard, and has short lessons: about a minute of explanation and a minute and a half of playing. The lessons don't depend on each other, so you can jump straight to the one you need and go on to real pieces.

Frequently asked questions

Why do people quit piano lessons?

In the 2014 UK Making Music survey the main reasons were loss of interest and other activities taking the time. Feeling less able also goes with stopping, and adults often stop at life changes. No study we found tested reading music as a reason.

How many children quit music lessons?

In a 2021 study of 3,303 students in the UK and Germany, about half had stopped music lessons and other musical activities by age 17. That covers all instruments, and piano players stopped less than guitar players at 16 and 17.

Is piano dropout getting worse?

We found no evidence of that. The 2014 UK survey found more children playing an instrument than in its earlier surveys.

Why do adults stop playing piano?

Research on adult amateur musicians in England found they lapse mostly at life transitions, such as a new job or a baby, and when the music no longer fits their goals. Many come back later.

Will iCanPiano keep me from quitting?

Nobody can promise that. iCanPiano Style takes the sharp and flat signs off the page, so there is less to decode and real pieces come sooner. Rhythm and practice are still part of the work.

All articles